The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus, and a few more movies

Watching a movie...

NEVERENDING FILM FESTIVAL
#402

I’m Not Rappaport (1996)
The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus (2009)
Imagination (1943)
The Immigrant (1917)
The Legend of Rita (2000)

every movie ever made, in alphabetical order
(we’re in the I’s, with random anti-alphabetical cheats)

I’m Not Rappaport (1996)

I saw the play I’m Not Rappaport at Seattle Rep in the 1980s, but all I remembered was that it’s about two old coots sharing a park bench, and that it’s good. The movie is better than I’d remembered the play.

“And the masses. Have you checked out your beloved masses lately? They still don’t give a crap.”

Walter Matthau plays an old radical rabblerouser, so full of BS about the old days you’re not sure you believe him when he says his name. Ossie Davis plays Carter, who’s still a janitor in his 80s, but about to be laid off. Between them there’s a movie’s worth of laughs and Meaningful Moments, plus Amy Irving as Matthau’s daughter, and Craig T. Nelson and Martha Plimpton as other folks in Central Park. Plimpton’s particularly good, of course.

Matthau’s a ham, Davis is wry. They’re grand together, but the film can’t decide whether to be realistic about them, or exaggerate for comedic effect. That’s a minor quibble, though. It’s an enjoyable movie.

Written and directed by Herb Gardner (Something Wild), based on his play.

Verdict: YES.

♦ ♦ ♦

The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus (2009)

Christopher Plummer plays Dr Parnassus, a grumpy old wizard who runs a traveling circus. Behind the stage is a magical mirrored gateway folks can walk through, but they shouldn’t, because it leads to alternate realities or something. “You don’t go through the mirror!” Doc Parnassus shouts. “Never! You know that!”

All through the movie, though, people keep going through the mirror, and when they’re not walking, running, or stumbling through the mirror, they’re shouting. More dialogue is shouted than spoken. Oy, my head hurts.

Lily Cole, Andrew Garfield, Heath Ledger, Johnny Depp, Colin Farrell, Jude Law, Verne Troyer, and Tom Waits travel along the mirror superhighway, but I never made sense of where they were headed, or why.

Many of the individual scenes are visually spectacular, because it’s by Terry Gilliam (Monty Python, Brazil), and Brazil gave me a headache, too, the first time I saw it. Even as that headache hammered me, though, I knew I wanted to see the movie again. Imaginarium provides no such urge.

Verdict: MAYBE.

♦ ♦ ♦

Imagination (1943)

This is an 8-minute cartoon, mostly poetry and singing, about a little girl’s dolls and sickness. The animation is colorful, the songs are kinda sticky, and there’s no dialogue. Never funny, but it’s not trying for funny. It’s a fairy tale, with dancing ragdolls and honestly too much singing.

Verdict: MAYBE.

♦ ♦ ♦

The Immigrant (1917)

This is a sweet and frequently funny Charlie Chaplin short, in which he sails the Atlantic and into New York Harbor. He passes instantly through immigration, which makes him as American as you or I. He finds a quarter so he’s no longer broke, finds a pretty lady so he’s no longer lonely, and has lunch served by the world’s worst waiter. Chuckles and smiles aplenty, but the best of it comes early on, when Chaplain does his famous ‘Tramp’ walk while on the ocean liner, wobbling from side to side with the waves, but never losing his footing.

IMDB says The Immigrant is 30 minutes, and maybe it was, once, but the longest version I could find is 25 minutes, linked above.

Verdict: YES.

♦ ♦ ♦

The Legend of Rita (2000)

It’s the 1970s, when political activism sometimes meant more than merely picketing. In West Germany, a small band of far-left fanatics blows stuff up, robs banks, etc. Rita Vogt is one of them, though she only joined because she had the hots for the group’s leader.

He’s not the same actor, but seems to be exactly the same character as the terrorist leader in The Baader Meinhof Complex — cold, mean, principled, but his main principle is being cold and mean.

The movie isn’t about him, though, which makes it batter. Like the title says, it’s about Rita. While breaking a comrade out of prison, things go wildly wrong, and Rita draws a gun, shoots, and kills a policeman. From there things go even wronger, until Rita and her cohorts are captured at the border by the East German secret police, the Stasi.

The film is based on real events and people, and in a wild but true twist, the Stasi doesn’t imprison the terrorists; it offers them safe harbor in East Germany — false identities, and the right to be part of the glorious workers’ paradise they’ve been fighting for. The only condition is, they’re not allowed contact with anyone from their old lives, or with each other.

Which seems a good place to end my synopsis. Telling you where the story leads would reduce the experience of the film, and it is definitely worth experiencing.

The film’s English-language title, Legend of Rita, is not so grandiose as it sounds. In German, the English word legend refers to the documents that support a cover story, so in essence the title translates as Rita’s Passport and Driver’s License.

The early action sequences are powerful, but the film’s long, pained stay in East Germany is unlike anything you’ve seen. It’s an entire nation of people who’ve given up, leaving Rita as perhaps the only person in the country who believes in its publicly-claimed ideals. There’s a great scene in the lunchroom, at the drab factory where she’s working, where Rita idealistically stands up for the principles of Marxism, and her co-workers look at her like she’s out of her mind.

She’s a radical, an active participant in acts of terror and violence, literally a killer, but the script and acting are so strong, you’re pulling for her even if you’re not radical yourself. The film’s second half, with less violence, is even more compelling. The Legend of Rita is a political film, sure, but at its heart it’s personal, and that’s what hits hardest.

Verdict: BIG YES.

9/2/2025

Logo illustration by Jeff Meyer. No talking once the lights dim, and only real butter on the popcorn, not that fake yellow stuff.

Neverending Film Festival

itsdougholland.com
← PREVIOUS           NEXT →


6 responses to “The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus, and a few more movies”

  1. granville Avatar
    granville

    I can’t remember, I might have recommended The Legend of Rita to you, and I just rewatched it again last week by chance. The East German scenes are as captivating as you describe, to the point I found it hard to remember the first 30 minutes of the movie at all. Some of the better dialog is between various Stasi agents too.

    “If you don’t explain the world to me, I won’t explain it to you either.”

    What I found most interesting though is the moments of sheer normalcy. I know that sounds ridiculous but in movies you rarely people on that side of the Wall at the beach, or the idea that a factory would have staff that were employed for the sole reason of planning holidays for the children of their employees.

    Volker Schlöndorff was (successfully) sued for the real life similarities of Rita with one that was still alive (Inge Viett). The German way of dealing with infamy is fascinating to me. Even infamous people have rights to privacy and publicity, and a bunch of Red Army Faction terrorists were given new identities after they were released from jail as assistance to starting their lives over, mirroring the “legend” some were given to start their lives over in East Germany.

    1. Doug Holland Avatar

      The Legend of Rita is really a wonderful film and deserves a better-written review than mine. The opening act, showing their crimes (I pause & hesitate to use that word) is thrilling enough that I thought it was going to be that movie, and that movie would’ve been fine with me, but it wasn’t that movie and that’s even better.

      Yes, it was you who recommended it, THANK YOU. If you have any further recommendations, I’m eager and itching for more stories of direct action. Here in real life, the choice seems to be between direct action and pretended action.

      Boggles the brain when I hear about how criminals are treated in other countries, like your account from Germany. After serving their time they’re still going to be infamous forever, hounded and hated, so why not give them new identities and papers? It’s a human kindness, which is flat out of the question in American prisons and punishment. I have never heard of it, don’t believe it would be seriously considered anywhere in redwhite&blueland.

      1. granville Avatar
        granville

        Brother I am far in your debt for movie recommendations. I’ve yet to see one miss!

        I’m currently at a loose end and unsure whether to dive into engagement or escapism. For some reason I started watching “The Gate of Heavenly Peace,” directed by Carma Hinton (the daughter of William Hinton, one of those wild figures whose name seems forgotten now) and suddenly realized “Hey my city might look like Tiananmen Square soon…” Watched through to the end, more depressed than engaged.

        One of the fascinating things about the whole incident, though, isn’t covered since the movie’s quite old now. The most radical student leaders who actually sabotaged an attempt to avoid bloodshed were Chai Ling and Li Lu. The first divorced her activist husband and married a hedge fund executive in Boston, converted to Christianity and was involved in a discrimination suit over an employee that suffered retaliation for refusing to participate in prayer. The second became a private equity titan in his own right and is heavily involved in securing funding for Chinese companies. Neither has the slightest interest in democracy in China and probably never did, but it’s interesting to note effective money is at scrubbing blood off your hands.

        1. Doug Holland Avatar

          Possibly they were plants from the beginning? Can real people, once *honest* participants in such a dangerous but righteous cause, evolve into hedge fund managers and the like? People change, but that’s a lot of change…

      2. granville Avatar
        granville

        Also, in some European countries there’s an attempt to separate punishment from public safety in determining if someone is to be incarcerated, as well as an attempt to understand if the public is at danger from a crime that was committed in very specific circumstances.

        There’s still a lot of hypocrisy about it though. Extreme case, but the French government and several others are terrified about the return their citizens that were captured on the battlefield fighting for ISIS because they’ll wind up with a very short sentence and then be released back into society. So they leave them where they were captured and refuse to bring them back, or just let the Iraqis execute them (again they’re not supposed to cooperate with a country that has the death penalty but they sitting on their hands for the most part and the unenlightened brown people do their dirty work. It’s all really grimy, nasty business.)

        And there’s an argument made that these “very specific circumstances” often covers for gender violence, which in almost every case means men beating or killing women. A great number of men who kill their wives have no criminal record or showed no prior tendency to violence. Chances are strong they won’t reoffend or present a public danger. There’s a famous case of a French musician who murdered the daughter of actor Jean-Louis Trintignant. He got sentenced to 8 years in the country where it happened, released after 4 after he was transferred back to France. I’m sure someone can explain this logically to me but I just can’t see past it.

        1. Doug Holland Avatar

          People in power do what’s pragmatic toward whatever their goals might be, which usually have nothing to do with right and wrong and justice. I can understand officials ambivalent about bringing back someone captured on the battlefield fighting for ISIS, but I’d want to pull the camera back for a wider view, like, who was fighting, who were they fighting against, and why.

          I’d forgive almost anyone overseas fighting against one of the many American occupations, for example. 100% self-defense.

          Are people angry at a murderer’s short sentence because the victim was the daughter of Jean-Louis Trintignant? I’d want the punishment to align with the punishment for someone who killed the daughter of Joe Blow, you know?

          I’m hesitant to even have an opinion in situations where I know nothing about the facts and the case, but I do believe in rehabilitation & second chances, and don’t believe in life in prison unless someone poses an actual danger of still being the kind of human who needs to be caged. Case by case & be cautious, but surely half the people in American prisons could be released with no big worries.

          Overall though, the world is full of shitty people doing shitty things, so I pay much more attention to the shitty people nearby, here in America, than to outrages overseas where I’d have to study up to understand what happened and what the issues were and are.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The maximum upload file size: 512 MB. You can upload: image, audio. Drop file here

Comments with attachments or multiple links are held for manual approval.