Or else.

Like most Americans, the assassination of Brian Thompson made me smile.

Thompson was CEO of UnitedHealthcare, where he was paid millions to oversee the denial of claims for people who’d paid monthly premiums and thought they had health insurance.

UnitedHealthcare denies almost 1/3 of all claims, the highest rate in the ‘industry’. Thompson was also a big fan of using AI to more efficiently deny more claims.

Every claim denied is a frantic worry, continued pain, a bankruptcy, or literally a death sentence. But it’s more profit for the insurance companies.

Brian Thompson, king of claim denials, killed people. Calculating how many would take heavy math, with numbers the insurance companies keep secret, so we’ll never know. What we know with certainty is that the insurance companies’ claim denials and their customers’ deaths will continue.

This is where I’m supposed to mention that I’m opposed to murder and assassination and such unpleasantness. And I am — I’m a pacifist! I could never shoot somebody, but three bullets in Brian Thompson’s back sure made me smile.

Violence is not the answer, we’re taught. Most people believe it, and heck, I’ve said it myself.

But you know what else isn’t the answer?

Peaceful picketing.

Sending a letter to your Congresscritter.

Or writing a blog post.

Good people have done all those things, without success since the 1960s — back when protests carried an undertone of “or else.”

“Or else” has faded away, so now, even when millions take to the street, nobody in power listens.

Remember the protests against launching the Gulf War, the Afghanistan War, remember the marches against police brutality, against genocide, for women’s rights… and remember what such peaceful protests accomplished. Nothing. Soon there will be protests against the looming round-up of immigrants, and those protests will accomplish nothing again.

What’s needed is more of “or else.”

12/10/2024

itsdougholland.com 
← PREVIOUS          NEXT →


5 responses to “Or else.”

  1. Jamie Avatar
    Jamie

    When the passive resistance fails, they don’t mention in grade school Social Studies that even Mahatma Gandhi “would rather have India resort to arms, than remain a helpless witness to her own dishonor”.

    1. Doug Holland Avatar

      All they ever say about Gandhi is peaceful resistance, but sometimes that doesn’t work. It only works if whatever you’re resisting has a conscience. Gandhi himself, as per your quote, had more nuance and smarts, and he doesn’t always boil down to peaceful resistance.

      “I do believe that where there is only a choice between cowardice and violence I would advise violence.”

      1. Jamie Avatar
        Jamie

        Yep

  2. Caitlin Johnstone Avatar
    Caitlin Johnstone

    People who say violence is never the answer are usually ignoring some massive and hugely consequential forms of systemic violence which gave rise to the violence they’re denouncing. It happened with October 7, and it happened with the health insurance CEO.

    Yesterday I asked my Twitter followers to complete the following sentence: “Instead of physically attacking the abusive plutocrats who expand their wealth and power by ruining lives and killing people, ordinary citizens should use the other options that are available to them to address such injustices, such as ______.”

    The responses were interesting. I got a lot of angry replies from people saying I was encouraging violence by posing this question, which is actually pretty revealing if you think about it. I didn’t actually encourage violence, I just asked people to list what the alternative options to violence were. If these respondents were aware of options besides violence for dealing with the abuses of wealthy oligarchs, it would never have occurred to them to see my question that way. They themselves see no way to resolve these abuses besides violence; they just think people should submit to continued abuse.

    1. Doug Holland Avatar

      Caitlin isn’t really here. She’s a high-fallutin’ professional writer, but I thought this snippet of hers was pertinent and faskinating so I posted it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The maximum upload file size: 512 MB. You can upload: image, audio. Drop file here

Comments with attachments or multiple links are held for manual approval.